| Class of 2009 | |
| Margy Acton | Lehigh University |
| Desiree Aramburu | Radford University |
| Caitlyn Ballweber | Florida Institute of Technology |
| Hope Baumgartner | Mount Mercy College |
| Rebecca Bograd | Illinois Institute of Technology |
| Christine Bowe | Saint Xavier University |
| Emily Cardwell | North Central College |
| Brittany Cardott | Millikin University |
| Mary Catherine Collier | Clarke College |
| Courtney Cunningham | University of Mississippi |
| Ali Deatsch | Elon University |
| Allie Gardner | Bradley University |
| Courtney Gosewisch | Purdue University |
| Katherine Gosewisch | Robert Morris-Chicago |
| Samantha Grams | Northern Illinois University |
| Brianne Graunke | Southern Illinois University Edwardsville |
| Kelly Griffin | Western Michigan University |
| Catherine Guido | Saint Norbert College |
| Sue Hayes | Northern Illinois University |
| Lindsay Homme | University of West Florida |
| Kaylee Kaminsky | Indiana Institute of Technology |
| Beth Kinsella | Harvard University |
| Jenna Litoborski | University of North Carolina Charlotte |
| Sami Loar | Florida Institute of Technology |
| Nikki Maes | Lewis University |
| Lexi Mastela | Florida Institute of Technology |
| Jessica McNellis | Bradley University |
| Kayla Mullaney | Saint Xavier University |
| Bridget Murphy | Western Illinois University |
| Marielle Oestermeyer | University of Mississippi |
| Jordan Pappas | Nova Southeastern University |
| Rachel Quackenbush | Indiana Wesleyan University |
| Kelsey Safranek | University of Illinois-Chicago |
| Sara Shannon | University of Maryland |
| Aubrey Sniegowski | University of Illinois-Chicago |
| Alise Tupuritis | Bradley University |
| Stephanie Viane | University of Wisconsin-Whitewater |
