| Class of 2010 | Class of 2011 | ||
| Beth Blackman | Drake University | Jocelynn Birks | University of Illinois |
| Lexi Finger | Colgate University | ||
| Annemarie Hickey | University of Wisconsin | ||
| MaryKate Imrie | University of Illinois–Chicago | ||
| Paige Kruse | Lehigh University | ||
| Sarah McCarthy | Furman University | ||
| Jill Paluch | University of Akron | ||
| Claire Randich | Butler University | ||
| Brianne Riley | University of Kansas | ||
| Sidney Sauter | West Virginia University | ||
| Sarah Scott | University of Texas at San Antonio | ||
| Lauren Zerante | Bradley University | ||
| Class of 2012 | |||
| Alexis Viliunas | University of Illinois | ||
